Red Flags: How to Spot Overhyped Supplements
The supplement industry is worth $50 billion. A lot of that money is made by confusing you. Here are the tactics they use and how to spot them.
Important: Not all supplements are scams. Many are genuinely helpful. The goal isn't to make you paranoid. It's to help you tell the difference between quality products and expensive urine.
Proprietary Blends
A "proprietary blend" is a list of ingredients without individual doses. The label shows the total weight of the blend, but not how much of each ingredient.
Example label:
Energy Matrix (2,500mg)
Caffeine, L-Tyrosine, Alpha-GPC, Rhodiola Rosea, Taurine
Why It's a Problem
- The first ingredient could be 2,400mg, leaving only 100mg for everything else
- Companies can list expensive ingredients but include trace amounts
- You can't compare products or verify you're getting effective doses
What Good Products Do:
List every ingredient with its exact dose on a separate line. No blends, no hiding. If they're proud of their formula, they show it.
Pixie Dusting
"Pixie dusting" is including an ingredient in such a small amount that it can't possibly do anything. But it lets them put it on the label.
The Trick:
"Contains Ashwagandha!" (50mg). Clinical dose is 300-600mg. That 50mg does nothing, but it sounds impressive in marketing.
Common Pixie-Dusted Ingredients
| Ingredient | Clinical Dose | Often Seen |
|---|---|---|
| Ashwagandha | 300-600mg | 50-100mg |
| Lions Mane | 500-1000mg | 100-200mg |
| Alpha-GPC | 300-600mg | 50-100mg |
| Citrulline | 6-8g | 1-2g |
| Beta-Alanine | 3.2-6.4g | 1-2g |
"Mega Doses" of Cheap Vitamins
"5,000% Daily Value of Vitamin B12!" Sounds impressive, right? It's actually a sign of lazy formulation.
The Reality:
B vitamins are cheap. Really cheap. Putting 5000% of B12 costs pennies. It lets them print impressive numbers while skimping on expensive ingredients.
The Problems With Mega-Doses
- Your body can only absorb so much. The rest becomes expensive urine
- Some vitamins (A, D, E, K) can accumulate and cause issues
- High B6 (over 100mg daily) can cause nerve damage long-term
What to Look For Instead:
Quality forms (methylcobalamin vs cyanocobalamin) matter more than quantity. 100-500% of quality forms beats 10,000% of cheap ones.
Meaningless Certifications
Not all certifications are equal. Some are rigorous third-party testing. Others are pay-to-play marketing logos.
Trust These
- NSF Certified for Sport - Rigorous testing
- USP Verified - Independent testing
- Informed Sport - Banned substance testing
- ConsumerLab Approved - Independent reviews
Less Meaningful
- "GMP Certified" - Basic requirement, not special
- "Doctor Recommended" - Which doctor? Paid?
- "Clinically Tested" - Tested how? Results?
- "Award Winning" - What award? Who gave it?
Miracle Claims
The more dramatic the claim, the more skeptical you should be. Real benefits are incremental and specific, not revolutionary.
"Lose 30 lbs in 30 days!"
No supplement does this safely.
"Boost testosterone 300%!"
Even TRT doesn't do this. Best supplements show 10-20% in deficient men.
"The ONE supplement that changes everything!"
Health doesn't work that way. Anyone claiming a magic bullet is selling something.
What Honest Claims Sound Like:
"Studies show 5-10% improvement in strength over 12 weeks." "May reduce anxiety symptoms in stressed adults." Specific, hedged, citing evidence.
Too Many Ingredients
When a product has 30+ ingredients, it's almost guaranteed that most are underdosed. There's only so much powder you can fit in a capsule or scoop.
The Math:
A typical capsule holds 500-700mg total. If there are 20 ingredients, that's 25-35mg each on average. Most nootropics need 200-600mg to work. The math doesn't add up.
Better Approach:
3-5 well-dosed ingredients beat 20+ underdosed ones. Simple, focused formulas with clinical doses of each ingredient actually work.
Quick Red Flag Checklist
- Proprietary blends hiding doses
- Ingredients below clinical doses
- Mega-doses of cheap B vitamins
- 20+ ingredients in one product
- Miracle claims without evidence
- No third-party testing mentioned
- Heavy influencer marketing, light on evidence
2+ red flags? Proceed with caution. 4+? Walk away.
The Bottom Line
The best supplements are often boring. Transparent labels, clinical doses, third-party testing. No fancy marketing, no influencer deals. If a product relies on hype instead of evidence, your money is better spent elsewhere.
Keep Learning
Not Sure About a Product?
Upload a photo of any supplement. We'll analyze it and flag any issues.
Check a Product